Although drinking water disinfection has significantly reduced mortality from waterborne diseases, the formation of potentially harmful disinfection by-products (DBPs) remains a concern today. These DBPs emerge from the reaction of dissolved organic matter (DOM) with chlor(am)ine during disinfection. Identifying these DBP precursors from heterogeneous and complex DOM mixtures is challenging and to address this, a novel membrane fractionation protocol was developed to isolate and identify the organic DBP precursors from fresh water sources. A tight ultrafiltration and nanofiltration membrane were carefully selected to partition DOM into three molecular weight (MW) fractions: high (>20 kDa), medium (0.3–20 kDa) and low (<0.3 kDa) as defined by high performance-size exclusion chromatography- total organic carbon analysis. A mathematical tool was developed to optimize the fractionation protocol. Therefore, ultrafiltration was executed before nanofiltration and the concentration factor was maximized without inducing fouling to obtain the purest fractions. The mathematical tool was also set in place to predict the necessary diafiltration factor for each individual fractionation experiment based on the initial organic matter composition of the surface water allowing the fractionation protocol to be effective at all times. The protocol was applied to surface water samples collected six times across three seasons yielding a fraction enriched in high MW compounds (up to 50 %), a fraction having more than 80 % of medium MW compounds and a fraction only containing low MW compounds. Although the medium MW fraction showed the highest reactivity for the majority of the investigated DBPs, the low MW fraction showed high reactivity for iodinated trihalomethanes during chlorination and for haloacetonitriles during chloramination. The high MW fraction had the lowest reactivity towards DBPs, which can have important implications for a drinking water treatment since this fraction is generally the most effectively removed by e.g. coagulation, while the more important fractions for DBP formation such as the medium and low MW compounds remain in the water until the disinfection step.